1947-48 - John Weimerskirch (147 lbs.)
1948-49 - Ted Burgaff (177 lbs.), Norman McDonnel (157 lbs.), John Weimerskirch (147 lbs.)
1950-51 - Jim McKeown (137 lbs.), George Pribyl (177 lbs.), John Weimerskirch* (147 lbs.)
1951-52 - Fred Grant (130 lbs.), Jim McKeown (137 lbs.), Clem Schoenbauer (Hwt.), John Weimerskirch (147 lbs.)
1952-53 - Bob Forster (Hwt.), Fred Grant (130 lbs.), Leo Kemper (177 lbs.), Jim McKeown* (137 lbs.), Jerre Miller (123 lbs.)
1953-54 - Louis Adderley (130 lbs.), Leo Kemper (Hwt.), Tom Kemply (167 lbs.), DeVaughn Nelson (157 lbs.), Jim Tachney (177 lbs.), Otto "Sy" Weber (147 lbs.)
1954-55 - Don Flynn (137 lbs.), DeVaughn Nelson (157 lbs.), Jim Tachney (177 lbs.)
1955-56 - Lawrence Betzler (157 lbs.), Don Flynn (137 lbs.), Mike Gibbs (147 lbs.), DeVaughn Nelson (167 lbs.)
1956-57 - John O'Fallon (167 lbs.)
1957-58 - Lawrence Betzler (147 lbs.), Jim Kuelbs (157 lbs.), Gary Sauer (123 lbs.)
1958-59 - Lawrence Betzler (147 lbs.), Tom Brudos (130 lbs.), Jerry Dalseth (137 lbs.), Jim Kuelbs (157 lbs.), Gary Sauer (123 lbs.)
1959-60 - Jim Kuelbs* (167 lbs.), Pat Murtaugh (157 lbs.)
1960-61 - Ben Pulkrabek (191 lbs.)
1961-62 - John Fritz (147 lbs.), John Fruth (130 lbs.), Tony Leifeld (123 lbs.), Ben Pulkrabek (Hwt.)
1963-64 - Don Schreifels (177 lbs.)
1964-65 - Maury Neifeld (191 lbs.), Don Schreifels (177 lbs.)
1966-67 - Pat Beyer (137 lbs.), Bob Westby (123 lbs.)
1968-69 - Gary Svendsen (115 lbs.)
1969-70 - Gary Svendsen (118 lbs.), Henry Wollmering (134 lbs.)
1970-71 - Terry Elfering (118 lbs.), Dennis Legatt (158 lbs.), Tom Miller (190 lbs.), Gary Svendsen (134 lbs.), Tom Svendsen (126 lbs.), Jerry Workman (167 lbs.)
1971-72 - Terry Elfering (118 lbs.), Joe Hayes (142 lbs.)
1972-73 - Al Bielat (177 lbs.), Terry Elfering (118 lbs.), Joe Hayes (142 lbs.), Dave Pulkrabek (158 lbs.), Tom Svendsen (134 lbs.)
1973-74 - Jay Huffman (118 lbs.), Greg Miller (Hwt.), Larry Osterhaus (158 lbs.), Tom Svendsen (134 lbs.), Jerry Workman (190 lbs.)
1974-75 - Greg Miller (Hwt.)
1975-76 - John Shimshock (150 lbs.)
1981-82 - Jim Goodman (167 lbs.)
1984-85 - John Schletty (167 lbs.)
1985-86 - Dave Barthel (118 lbs.)
1986-87 - Dave Barthel (118 lbs.)
1990-91 - Scott Fernholz (142 lbs.)
1991-92 - Scott Fernholz (142 lbs.)
1993-94 - Chris Grothe (190 lbs.), Jason Scherber (158 lbs.)
1994-95 - Chris Grothe (190 lbs.), Jason Scherber* (167 lbs.), Rich Schneckenberger (158 lbs.), Dan Tschudi (142 lbs.)
1996-97 - John Newman (167 lbs.), Matt Ryan* (158 lbs.), Dan Tschudi (150 lbs.)
1997-98 - John Newman* (167 lbs.), Brandon Novak (190 lbs.)
1999-00 - Jeremy Abfalter (165 lbs.)
2000-01 - Brandon Novak* (197 lbs.)
2002-03 - Dan Fiecke (197 lbs.)
2003-04 - Dan Fiecke (197 lbs.), Matt Vos* (125 lbs.)
*Carl Larson Trophy as MIAC Outstanding Wrestler
